Minutes for Meeting of November 2nd
2007
The Haven, Gabriola, B.C.
Attending:
Members: Randy Wong, Paul Robillard, John Gill
Board: Bill Chalmers (Chair), Dave Tyler, David
Raithby, Connie Munro
Ex-Officio Directors: Randy Wong (also Member),
Gerry Owen
Friends of Haven: Ron Adkins
Management: John Shields, Christine Purfield, Rachel
Davey, Lorena Lavers, Bill Leuze, Gwen Ewan.
Guests & Others: Carole Ames (Faculty
Committee)
Regrets: Dick Sass, Linda Nicholls, Rick
Jackson, Steve Davis, Laurie Kelley, Bryan Croeni
Recorder: Christine Purfield
1.
Call to
Order at 10:10a.m. by the Chair.
The Vision and Mission statements were
read by Connie Munro.
2.
Check-In.
All present checked-in
3.
Agenda
addition.
David Raithby requested the addition of “Proxy Votes”.(amended
February 29 2008) The Chair suggested the subject be discussed prior to
any proxy votes being needed and, in the event no proxy votes were needed this
meeting, would be discussed at another Board meeting. Agreed by David.
Members’ presentation under 7 (a) will be moved to immediately
follow 3. Agreed by all.
Meeting moved to “In-Camera” for the
Members’ presentation and discussion at 10.20a.m. All non-voting Directors,
management, and guests left. Remaining: Bill Chalmers, John Shields, Dave
Tyler, Connie Munro, David Raithby, Randy Wong, Paul Robillard, John Gill.
Board meeting reconvened at 2.35 p.m.
Paul Robillard and John Gill absent.
4.
General
Board Affairs.
a.
Approval
of Minutes
An amendment to the September 7th minutes
was noted: in the statement related to Dave Tyler not being in support of the
sole Director model for P.D. Seminars, Dave would like an amendment to clarify
that his reason for non-support is due to a lack of information currently being
available to him.
Moved
and seconded,
That
the September 7th 2007 minutes be adopted as amended.
Motion
carried unanimously.
b.
Old
Business and Action Items: –
Bill Chalmers
Removed.
c.
Executive
Director and Management reports
i.
Executive
Director – John Shields
John referred to his written report. With
respect to recent e-mails and his memo regarding the restructuring, the
professional advice received was that we should be proceeding for a number of
reasons.
ii.
Operations
– Bill Leuze
Bill had no additions to his written
report.
iii.
Programmes
– Rachel Davey
Rachel discussed two additions to her
written report: 1) a project focused on using “Haven Models” as a marketing
tool and 2) Haven will undertake the design and creation of brochures for all
our courses – including non-proprietary – to create a consistent and
professional look.
A question was raised regarding the
timing of the event to honour Ben and Jock. This will be held on January 1st
2008 between 1.30p.m. and 3.p.m. The Phoenix Auditorium will be renamed the “Wong
McKeen Phoenix Auditorium”. A piece of stained glass artwork will be
commissioned to commemorate the occasion and will be movable to hang in either
a window or cover a door. Photographs of Ben and Jock over the last twenty five
years will be displayed.
iv.
Interns
– Gwen Ewen
Gwen had no additions to her written
report.
v.
Faculty
– Carole Ames
Carole had no additions to her written
report.
vi.
Finance
– Lorena Lavers
Lorena distributed and discussed the P.D.
Seminars Ltd. budget for 2008. The budget and Lorena’s memorandum to the Chair
of the Audit & Finance Committee will be added to the agenda package. The
budget addresses staff wage increases, tuition fee increases, room rate
increases, and the expansion of errors and omissions insurance to cover
Faculty, interns, and assistants. The capital expenditure budget is in “draft”
form only as management is still refining it. The Haven Foundation 2008 budget
will be presented after the end of the year as it is based on funds on hand as
at December 31st 2007. A question was raised regarding the $50,000
allocated for increased marketing expenses. This is for technical marketing
assistance and Rachel is working on a request for proposals.
Dave Tyler still has questions around the
budget proposal and he will be consulting with John Shields to have them
answered.
Moved and seconded:
Resolved to approve the 2008
operating budget for P.D. Seminars Ltd.
Motion carried.
5.
Committee
Reports.
a.
Audit
and Finance –
Dave Tyler
Dave clarified his comments in his report
regarding the disbursement quota for Haven Foundation. The disbursement
shortfall for 2006 was an anomaly. He stressed that the 80/20 rule needs to be
adhered to.
6.
Other
Business.
a.
Restructuring – John Shields
John summarized the report from Ernst and
Young. In their opinion, there will be no corporate tax consequences on the
donation of assets from P.D. Seminars Ltd. to Haven Foundation. An appraisal of
the property will be done mid-November. The amount of the transfer will be
included in our 80/20 disbursement quota calculation and is being reviewed by
our legal advisors.
Moved and seconded: that the motion of
the previous Board meeting is amended to read as follows:
It is moved that the CFO is
directed, in appropriate consultation with the E.D., (and Gerry Owen if
necessary), and the Chairs of the Board and the Audit and Finance Committee, to
proceed with necessary appraisals, tax accountant, and tax attorney
consultations toward the end of transferring all property (real, registered,
intellectual, furnishings, and equipment) and staff from P.D. Seminars to The Haven
Foundation as rapidly as prudent.
November 2nd 2007 –
the Board of Directors confirm their intention to move forward with this
agreement.
Motion carried unanimously.
b.
Board
Committee Structures –
John Shields
i.
Proposed
terms of reference – Education and Standards Committee
A concern was raised regarding the voting
capacity of Faculty members on this committee. John clarified that a consensus
model would be used for this committee. That is, the committee will work
through to agreement and no one on the committee will need a vote. The draft
terms of reference will include a note to this effect. The Education and
Standards Committee will be active immediately and work through to June 2008. It
will be evaluated at that time.
ii.
Proposed
terms of reference – Education and Dispute Appeals.
Management will be assuming more of a
direct responsibility for disputes arising in relation to faculty, interns, and
assistants. In the event of a dispute or a complaint, faculty, interns, and
assistants need a place to appeal. The terms of reference were summarized.
Moved
and seconded:
Resolved that the terms of
reference for the Education and Standards and Education and Dispute Appeals Committees
be approved.
Motion carried unanimously.
All other proposed terms of reference for
committees will be tabled until the June 2008 meeting.
c.
Summary
of the closed session with Members – Bill Chalmers and Randy Wong
At the request of a non Board
participant, a brief summary was given of the discussion of the Board with the
Members.
d.
Resignation
– Dave Tyler
Dave Tyler announced he was resigning as
Chair of the Audit and Finance Committee. He has a more cautious approach to
risk assessment than the board or members. He speaks from his personal
philosophy and his own experience as an ED/CEO. He has a heavy volunteer
background and has always acted alongside management. He does not want to
hamper the board but he is used to a bigger governance overlap between
directors and management. He will also resign as a director and wishes the
Board/Haven success.
The Board expressed its appreciation for
Dave’s work as a Director and as the Chair of the Audit and Finance Committee.
Termination: 3.25p.m.
Next Board meeting: To be announced.
Approved: February 29th 2008